Been meaning to check out Scarrs on one of our NYC trips for a while now! Preferred the classic slice over the sicilian (for texture as well as the fact that the thicker slice didnt get heated up enough in the oven). Not busy at all on a weekday (Monday) at lunch, so you'll def be able to swing by and easily grab a slice or two (or three) to eat there. The margherita is a solid pick per usual, but the hot boy is a nice sweet and spicy kick!

WOW! Now this is some good pizza! Second best to Bolinis in Monterey Park, CA. At least I have a spot on the East Coast that is almost as good as home! See you soon NY!

One of the best pizza spot in NYC. The service was quick and friendly. They will add some honey on your pizza if you ask them. Their pizza crust is very crispy and thin. They have a nice bar setting in the back so you can enjoy some drinks while having your pizza. Yes. They have restroom. Not sure about parking but i think it is best if you walk here.

Browsing through my AppleNews one day I discovered 'This NYC pizza was just named one of the best in the world.' Best in the world? Sure enough, here was the list. Look at No 2!!! The best pizzas in the world (prepared by the Time Out Group, March 7, 2025 contributed by Food & Drink Editor Morgan Carter for Time Out Group): 1. Pizzeria da Attilio in Naples, Italy 2. Scarr's Pizza in New York City, U.S.A. 3. Pizza Marumo in Tokyo, Japan 4. 180g Pizzeria Romana in Rome, Italy 5. Bella Brutta in Sydney, Australia 6. Diamond Slice in Copenhagen, Denmark 7. Dough Hands in London, U.K. 8. Novo in Cape Town, South Africa 9. Oobatz in Paris, France 10. Baldoria in Madrid, Spain I had to go and did. It was a mid weekday afternoon so I avoided the weekend and the later evening crowds and after a short wait ordered a single slice with mushrooms for a cost of just over $6. These were fresh mushrooms, not out of can. The crust was thin, cheese was just right, and it truly was a well groomed slice of NYC pizza. So why 4 stars and not 5? Well, probably my fault for not ordering 'well done' on the warm up but it was just a tad soggy and not that snappy crispy thin crust I was hoping for. Take nothing away (except 1 star) because when you go be sure to order well done or order your own Pie. There is a nice seating area at the Bar, high tops next to the Bar and seating in the back with table service. Scarr himself, the Owner, is there to oversee and is most friendly and hospitable. I enjoyed the experience as I'm sure you will too. Scarr is a most stop when in the area or near. I walked over from Chinatown to experience the 2nd best Pizza in the World! It was well worth the walk!! Enjoy!!!

Great pizza spot! We found out about Scarr's Pizzeria on YouTube and decided to check it out. We made a reservation, and when we arrived, we were glad we did--there were so many people waiting outside. However, it would have been fine to walk in, as they offer to-go orders at the front. The pizza was delicious! We tried about seven different slices, and every single one was amazing. The service was fast and efficient, and the atmosphere had a cozy café-style vibe. Definitely a place we'd come back to and highly recommend!

This pizza shop has a great vibe. It's unpretentious and laid back. They have a grab and go counter at the front, a full bar with high top seating, and additional tables against the wall and towards the back of the restaurant. We sat at the bar. It was a little hard to get the employees' attention to place our order, but not too bad. The margherita slice was delicious. Thin, floppy dough. Fresh basil. Chunky sauce. A balanced soft and crispy crust. They had a great playlist of old and new school hip hop and r&b. Definitely worth a visit.

Decent pizza spot. I came here on a Sunday evening and there was a small wait. The spot has two sections: a sit-down, restaurant section and a to-go, by-the-slice spot with only bar (aka, you would have to stand and eat your pizza). I got a mushroom pizza and a jalapeno/pepperoni pizza and both were pretty solid. They're both on the thinner side and the toppings were pretty solid. I just wish that they had a bit more options and variety in their by-the-slice orders. Nonetheless, it was pretty standard pizza (loved how they added a hot oil to the jalapeno/pepperoni pizza though!).

Solid spot for that quintessential New York slice. Scarr's serves classic pizza in big, hearty slices. I loved the usual Pepperoni Pizza and how cheesy and slightly crunchy it was. They also have a selection of local beers on tap, which is great for visitors looking to try new brews. Do note that seating here is limited in the evenings, as you do need to buy a whole pie if you want to be seated. During the day, it's more lax and you can be seated if just ordering slices. Service is pretty solid and the venue is charming. Definitely a spot to try for those looking for good pizza.